Why Reading Order Matters: Deciphering Complexity
The Malazan Book of the Fallen is a sprawling, epic fantasy series that has captivated readers worldwide with its intricate worldbuilding, compelling characters, and morally gray narratives. However, the sheer scope and complexity of the series can be daunting for newcomers. Often hailed as one of the greatest, but most challenging, fantasy series ever written, the question of “where do I even *begin*?” plagues many potential readers. This article aims to provide clear guidance on the various Malazan reading order options, helping you choose the best path to embark on this unforgettable journey through the Malazan universe. No single “right” way exists to experience this saga, but understanding the different approaches will ensure a more fulfilling and enjoyable exploration.
The Malazan Book of the Fallen is not your typical fantasy series. It’s known for its immersive yet demanding narrative style. Steven Erikson, the primary author, throws you headfirst into a vast world teeming with countless characters, sprawling continents, and interwoven timelines. The prose is often dense, tackling philosophical themes and moral ambiguities. Exposition is frequently delayed, employing an “in media res” storytelling technique that can initially leave readers disoriented. Furthermore, the series is expanded upon by Ian Cameron Esslemont, with his complementary novels exploring different perspectives and corners of the Malazan world.
Choosing a Malazan reading order significantly impacts your understanding and overall enjoyment. A haphazard approach can lead to confusion, missed connections, and a diminished appreciation for the intricate tapestry that Erikson and Esslemont have woven. The right order will allow you to gradually acclimate to the world, develop a connection with the characters, and fully grasp the overarching narrative threads.
The Core Choices: Exploring Different Reading Orders
There are primarily two generally accepted approaches to reading Malazan, although some adventurous readers forge their own paths. These options offer distinct experiences, each with unique advantages and potential drawbacks.
Publication Order: The Classic Approach
This is the most straightforward method, following the order in which the main series by Steven Erikson was originally published. This is often considered the “purist” or “intended” reading order, although the authors themselves have generally encouraged readers to find the order that works best. The publication order is as follows:
Gardens of the Moon
Deadhouse Gates
Memories of Ice
House of Chains
Midnight Tides
The Bonehunters
Reaper’s Gale
Toll the Hounds
Dust of Dreams
The Crippled God
The Allure of Publication Order
The primary benefit of adhering to the publication order lies in experiencing the story as the initial readers did. It allows you to gradually uncover the mysteries of the Malazan world alongside Erikson’s intended pacing. The gradual introduction of characters, continents, and magical systems provides a gentler learning curve, even if the beginning can feel overwhelming. This order also allows you to witness Erikson’s evolving writing style and the deepening of his thematic explorations as the series progresses.
The Drawbacks of Publication Order
Despite its merits, the publication order isn’t without its challenges. *Gardens of the Moon*, the first book, is notorious for its initial density and abrupt immersion. Many readers find it difficult to penetrate, which can deter them from continuing the series. The sheer number of characters and storylines introduced early on can also be overwhelming, potentially leading to confusion and a sense of being lost. Additionally, this order focuses solely on Steven Erikson’s core narrative, delaying exposure to Ian Cameron Esslemont’s contributions to the wider Malazan tapestry.
Publication Order with Esslemont Integration: A More Complete Picture
This approach expands upon the traditional publication order by weaving in the novels written by Ian Cameron Esslemont. These books run parallel to Erikson’s main series, offering alternative perspectives on events, exploring different regions of the world, and introducing new characters and storylines. Integrating Esslemont’s novels provides a broader and more comprehensive understanding of the Malazan universe.
A recommended integration, although subjective and open to personal adjustment, would look something like this:
Gardens of the Moon
Deadhouse Gates
Memories of Ice
House of Chains
Midnight Tides
The Bonehunters
Reaper’s Gale
Toll the Hounds
Stonewielder (Esslemont) – Can be read after Toll the Hounds or before Dust of Dreams
Dust of Dreams
The Crippled God
Orb, Sceptre, Throne (Esslemont) – Can be read after The Crippled God or before Assail
Blood and Bone (Esslemont)
Assail (Esslemont)
Benefits of Esslemont Integration
Integrating Esslemont’s novels offers a more holistic view of the Malazan world. It fills in some of the gaps left unanswered in Erikson’s books, providing additional context and shedding light on unexplored corners of the narrative. You’ll encounter new characters, cultures, and magical systems, enriching your overall understanding of the Malazan universe. Esslemont’s stories often provide different perspectives on events depicted in Erikson’s books, adding layers of complexity and nuance.
Challenges of Esslemont Integration
Integrating Esslemont’s novels isn’t without its own set of challenges. Some readers find that it disrupts the flow of Erikson’s main narrative, feeling like a detour from the core storyline. Esslemont’s writing style differs from Erikson’s, which can be jarring for some readers. While both authors contribute to the same world, their storytelling approaches, character development, and prose styles vary. The placement of Esslemont’s novels within the reading order is also subjective, with no universally agreed-upon sequence. Finding the right integration point can be tricky and potentially disrupt the pacing of the overall narrative.
Chronological Order: A Bold Undertaking
This reading order attempts to assemble the books based on the chronological timeline of events within the Malazan world. This is by far the most complex and challenging approach, requiring extensive knowledge of the lore and intricate timelines. It is generally not recommended for first-time readers, as it can significantly increase the risk of confusion and frustration.
Attempting a chronological read requires painstaking research and meticulous planning. The timelines are often ambiguous and interwoven, making it difficult to definitively place events in a precise order. The shifting perspectives and unreliable narrators further complicate matters, making it challenging to determine the true sequence of events.
Which Malazan Reading Order is Right for You? Recommendations Based on Reader Type
The optimal Malazan reading order ultimately depends on your individual preferences, reading style, and goals. Here’s a guide based on different reader profiles:
For the Newcomer: Embrace Simplicity
For first-time readers venturing into the Malazan world, the publication order of the core Steven Erikson series is strongly recommended. Start with *Gardens of the Moon* and progress through the series in the order it was released. Patience is key. Reread passages when needed and don’t be afraid to consult online resources for clarification. Focus on enjoying the journey, rather than getting bogged down in every detail. The initial complexity will gradually dissipate as you become more familiar with the world and its inhabitants.
For the Completionist: Seek the Whole Picture
If you desire a comprehensive understanding of the Malazan universe from the outset, then the publication order with integrated Ian Cameron Esslemont novels is the way to go. Refer to the recommended integration list provided earlier in this article. Be prepared to embrace different writing styles and perspectives. Understand that Esslemont’s novels offer a valuable complement to Erikson’s main narrative, enriching the overall experience.
For the Veteran Reader: Rediscover the World
For those who have already read the main Malazan Book of the Fallen series, there are several avenues to explore. You might delve into Ian Cameron Esslemont’s novels to gain a new perspective on familiar events. Alternatively, you could attempt a chronological read, challenging your understanding of the timeline and uncovering hidden connections. Rereading the main series with a newfound appreciation for the world and its characters can also be incredibly rewarding.
Beyond the Main Series: Additional Malazan Materials
Beyond the main ten-book series and Esslemont’s contributions, the Malazan universe continues to expand. Steven Erikson has penned novellas, such as the *Kharkanas Trilogy*, offering a glimpse into the ancient history of the Malazan world. He has also embarked on a sequel trilogy, *The Witness Trilogy*, continuing the story after the events of *The Crippled God*.
These supplementary materials are best enjoyed after completing the main series, or at least most of it, to avoid spoilers and maximize your understanding of the overarching narrative. A possible reading order might place the Kharkanas Trilogy after The Crippled God, but before embarking on The Witness Trilogy. Ultimately, the placement of these materials is up to your personal preference.
Tips for Reading the Malazan Series: A Guide to Survival
Navigating the Malazan series can be a challenging but ultimately rewarding experience. Here are some helpful tips to guide you on your journey:
Utilize online resources like the Malazan Wiki and dedicated forums for reference and clarification.
Don’t hesitate to ask questions and seek explanations from fellow readers.
Take breaks when needed. Don’t try to rush through the books.
Reread key passages or chapters to solidify your understanding.
Embrace the ambiguity and complexity of the world. Some questions are intentionally left unanswered.
Don’t be discouraged by *Gardens of the Moon*. It gets significantly better as the series progresses.
Conclusion: Embark on Your Journey
Remember, there is no single “right” way to experience the Malazan Book of the Fallen. The optimal Malazan reading order depends on your individual preferences and goals. Choose the path that resonates with you, embrace the challenge, and prepare to be immersed in one of the most captivating and rewarding fantasy series ever written. The Malazan universe awaits, filled with epic battles, complex characters, and philosophical explorations that will stay with you long after you finish the final page. Start your Malazan journey today!
